Lawn Sweeper vs. Bagger: Which One is Right for You?
A lawn sweeper uses a relatively soft bristle to sweep up garden debris, while a bagger is attached to your lawn mower to collect grass clippings. Both are efficient in their purposes, but perform slightly different functions. Choosing between a lawn sweeper and a bagger depends on your yard maintenance needs.
To help you discover which is the best option for you, Mowrator USA has compiled this guide. We’ll cover a thorough definition of what a lawn sweeper and bagger are, their pros and cons, and how to choose the right one.
Key Takeaways
- A lawn sweeper benefits gardeners by typically working independently of electricity while covering large areas of ground.
- Lawn sweepers collect stones and debris more effectively than baggers.
- Baggers are better for maintaining well manicured lawns, whereas lawn sweepers don’t cut grass.
- Lawn sweepers require more maintenance than baggers because of their design.
How does a Lawn Sweeper Work?
We’ve summarized the main differences between how lawn sweepers and baggers work below:
| Lawn Sweepers | Baggers |
|---|---|
| Works by combining brushes with a hopper | Works in tandem with a lawn mower |
| Brushes rotate and sweep up garden debris into the hopper (e.g., grass clippings, leaves, stones, acorns, twigs) | Bag or container attaches to the lawn mower |
| Hopper stores the debris for emptying later | Collects debris (e.g., grass clippings, leaves) while you mow your lawn |
| Hopper prevents the debris from escaping back onto the lawn | Container or bag must be manually emptied when full to prevent cut grass from falling out back onto the garden surface |
Different Kinds of Lawn Sweepers
There are three kinds of lawn sweepers to consider for your garden maintenance:
- A push lawn sweeper that works with manual pushing
- A tow lawn sweeper, ideal for dragging behind a ride-on mower or tractor
- Powered lawn sweepers that work with batteries, gas, or electricity
Lawn Sweeper vs. Bagger: What are the Pros and Cons?
The lawn sweeper’s main advantage lies in its large capacity and ability to function independently of a mower; however, it struggles with wet debris and uneven terrain. In contrast, the bagger’s major benefit is that it excels in convenience by collecting clippings while mowing and handling bumpy landscapes well. The downside, however, is the bagger’s smaller size, which requires frequent emptying. Here’s a detailed comparison.
| Feature | Lawn Sweeper | Bagger |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiency | Picks up leaves, twigs, acorns, pine needles, and grass clippings effectively | Best for collecting grass clippings directly while mowing |
| Ease of Use | Requires pushing or towing, but does not need to be attached to a mower | Attaches directly to the mower and works as you mow |
| Capacity | Generally has a larger hopper for collecting more debris before emptying | Needs frequent emptying due to smaller bag size |
| Versatility | Can be used even when the mower is not in operation | Only works when the mower is running |
| Effectiveness on Wet Debris | Less effective on wet leaves and grass | Can clog easily when picking up wet grass |
| Use on Uneven Terrain | Works best on flat or slightly uneven surfaces | Works well on uneven terrain since it moves with the mower |
What Else Should You Know About Lawn Sweepers and Baggers?
Other factors you should know about lawn sweepers and baggers are:
- How they should be maintained to ensure optimal efficiency
- How to empty each one and how often
- How good of an investment each one is, depending on your needs
Maintenance
Maintenance for lawn sweepers includes cleaning after every use, and inspecting at least once every 3 months. The type of grass you have can also affect how often your lawn sweeper should be maintained. Because they have bristles and a hopper, these can get worn over time.
The brush of a lawn sweeper can be replaced if it begins to wear out, and the hopper may require some repair or a replacement if damaged. Lawn sweepers also have wheels, and these can become loose or damaged after multiple uses.
Overall, lawn sweepers have more bolts and moving parts that need tightening and lubrication compared to baggers. Baggers don’t require much maintenance at all. It takes a lot to break or tear a bagger, so this is a long-term consideration when choosing between these two options.
Emptying
You’ll need to empty both lawn sweepers and baggers after using them. To empty a bagger, simply detach it from your lawn mower and dump the contents onto your compost heap or trash can.
Emptying a lawn sweeper is similar, but with some models it can be more complicated. Most lawn sweepers come with a lever that tips the contents out of the hopper. Others come with hopper bags that can be removed, emptied, and put back.
Cost and Value Considerations
When it comes to the initial cost of a lawn sweeper versus a bagger, baggers will always win because they are much cheaper. But the long-term benefits of a lawn sweeper may win you over because of its effectiveness in maintaining large areas.
Also, remember that a bagger is nothing without a lawn mower. A lawn mower that comes with a grass bag attachment is a good investment if all you want to do is cut the grass and not have to rake it up afterward.
How to Choose Between a Lawn Sweeper and a Bagger
To choose between a lawn sweeper and a bagger, consider the size of your lawn and what type of debris you want to remove. Also consider how much storage you have, whether you can maintain a lawn sweeper long term, and what attachments will be required. Let’s examine these aspects in detail:
| Consideration | Lawn Sweeper | Bagger |
|---|---|---|
| Your Lawn Size | Ideal for medium to large lawns, especially with a tow-behind model | Suitable for small to medium lawns, but can be used for large yards with frequent emptying |
| Common Debris Type in Your Yard | Works well for leaves, twigs, pine needles, acorns, and grass clippings | Best for collecting grass clippings directly while mowing |
| Convenience | Requires a separate pass over the lawn, but collects more debris in one go | Collects clippings while mowing, but requires regular emptying |
| Your Storage Capacity | Takes up more storage space because of its larger size | More compact and easier to store |
| Maintenance Habits | Requires occasional cleaning of brushes and the hopper | Needs frequent unclogging and cleaning of the bag |
| Your Yard Terrain | Works best on flat or slightly uneven terrain | Works well on both flat and uneven terrain |
| Attachment Requirement | Can be used independently of a lawnmower | Must be attached to a compatible lawnmower |
With the Mowrator S1 models, you get the best of both worlds. Our standard, high-lift, and mulching blades allow you to customize your mowing experience — whether you prefer bagging for a clean finish or mulching for a healthier lawn. Smarter, hassle-free mowing starts here. Upgrade to Mowrator today!
Lawn Sweeper vs. Bagger FAQs
Can a lawn bagger be used with any lawnmower?
No, a lawn bagger can't be used with any lawn mower. Some lawn mowers are not compatible with baggers at all, while others require specific baggers for their associated models. If you want a bagger, consider choosing the right mower, the correct deck size, and one that has a mounting system to accommodate a bagger.
Are there different types of lawn baggers?
Yes, there are different types of lawn baggers dependent on the mower brand and model. Most baggers are attached at the rear of the mower, while some are placed on the side. Zero-turn mowers often have dual baggers, and larger lawn mowers have triple bags.
Do lawn sweepers damage the grass?
No, lawn sweepers don’t damage your grass. They use brushes to roll debris into the hopper, which can be manually emptied later. The bristles of these brushes are relatively soft so that they do not damage your grass. Because of their softness, debris may build up in the bristles over time, so you’ll have to maintain your lawn sweeper brush.
Back to Top: Lawn Sweeper vs. Bagger: Which One is Right for You?